[Show all top banners]

cybernepali
Replies to this thread:

More by cybernepali
What people are reading
Subscribers
Subscribers
[Total Subscribers 4]

tragicomic

Mr. D

Tyo Din

jetho390
:: Subscribe
Back to: Kurakani General Refresh page to view new replies
 Nepali man found innocent after spending 15 years in prison
[VIEWED 6914 TIMES]
SAVE! for ease of future access.
Posted on 10-29-12 8:04 AM     Reply [Subscribe]
Login in to Rate this Post:     0       ?    
 


Japan prosecutors say Govinda Prasad Mainali is innocent

   
  After spending 15 years in jail‚ Mainali found not guilty in 1997 murder after rape

THT ONLINE/FILE

In this file photo of June 16, 2012, Govinda Mainali, who languished for 15 years in Japan’s jail arrives with his family in Nepal.

THT ONLINE

"We are extremely sorry for keeping him detained for a very long time"
KATHMANDU: Prosecutors at the Tokyo High Court on Monday said that Govinda Prasad Mainali (45), who was convicted of killing a Japanese woman after raping her in 1997, was not guilty, making his acquittal certain, Kyodo News Agency reported.

Reading a document at the court in the retrial of the case, the prosecutors said that Mainali was "innocent" and "the possibility of another person being the culprit cannot be denied" based on current evidence.

"We are extremely sorry for keeping him detained for a very long time," Takayuki Aonuma, deputy head of the Tokyo High Public Prosecutors Office, said in a statement.

Mainali, who served 15 years in jail, had filed a plea for retrial in 2005. He was freed in June this year after DNA test results showed that he was not the killer. He was subsequently deported to Nepal.

The DNA in a sample taken from the victim’s nails did not match that of Mainali but it matched that of semen found inside the victim's body leading to the Tokyo High Court granting him a retrial, according to the Kyodo News Agency.

A permanent resident of Ilam district in eastern Nepal. Mainali had moved to Japan to work at a restaurant.

In December 2000, he was convicted of the 1997 murder of former Tokyo Electric Power Co. employee and was sentenced to life in prison. The verdict was finalised in October 2003.

The reinvestigation was made possible by an April 2010 revision of the criminal law that abolished the statute of limitations in capital crimes, according to The Japan Times.
 
Posted on 10-29-12 8:05 AM     Reply [Subscribe]
Login in to Rate this Post:     0       ?    
 

Sunday, Oct. 28, 2012

Mainali brother details family's ordeal

Kyodo

KATMANDU — This is a special article written by Indra Prasad Mainali on behalf of his younger brother, Govinda Prasad Mainali, who was freed from a Yokohama prison last summer:

 

News photo
Indra Prasad Mainali

A few days ago, my family celebrated Dashain, the biggest Hindu festival, with unrestrained joy for the first time in 15 years.

The reason for this is that my younger brother, Govinda Prasad Mainali, is back after spending 15 years in a prison in Japan for the robbery and murder of a woman in Tokyo.

He did not commit those crimes. The emergence of new evidence one after another in the past year or so supporting his innocence must have left no doubt in anyone's mind by now.

In these 15 years, we missed Govinda, especially during festivals.

Whenever someone in the family announced plans to do something special during a festival, another member would object, saying it was not proper to celebrate since a member of the family was being wrongly held in a prison on foreign soil for crimes he did not commit.

Someone or other in the family would start weeping, thinking about Govinda and his seemingly endless wait for justice. This meant that festivals like Dashain brought us more sadness than joy.

But things have changed for the better now.

Govinda is back and people in my country have come to know from local media that my family does not have a murderer nor a thief as its member.

Of late, there has been a big change in the way Nepali society looks at our family, but things were different until recently.

Many acquaintances chose to maintain a distance from our family after Govinda was arrested and later convicted for life. Some of them said things behind our backs, such as my younger brother went to a foreign land, did something unspeakable and landed in jail.

Fortunately, close relatives and friends were always sympathetic to us, as they knew that ours is not the kind of family that could produce a murderer. Thanks to our family's respectable track record, they always believed that Govinda had been trapped by circumstances.

Things have become so much better now. Almost nobody in Nepal has any doubts about Govinda's innocence.

In fact, many took his return to Nepal in June as something that happened after he won in court, although in reality a final court verdict is still due.

After his return, relatives, friends and acquaintances who are in touch with us have been congratulating me for getting my brother back after such a long fight for justice. They also thank me for taking care of Govinda's family for such a long time.

In short, there is no need any more for members of my family to leave for work harboring fear that someone might call us the family of a murderer and thief.

For a respectable and reasonably well-heeled family like ours, even an accusation of a crime is a great tragedy, let alone the arrest and conviction of a family member for a terrible crime such as murder.

Govinda's return to Nepal and local media coverage about the injustice he faced has lifted an enormous burden from the tender shoulders of Mithila and Alisha — my nieces and Govinda's daughters.

They grew up facing questions from classmates why their father never attended functions at school. It was always their mother who showed up and never their father. Their close friends knew the reality, but not everyone knew. Now everyone in their friends' circle knows about the misfortune that befell them (and) sympathize with the two girls.

When Govinda returned in June, we had fears that he might have developed serious health problems after spending such a long time in confinement. Fortunately, comprehensive health checkups conducted on him in Katmandu did not reveal any serious health problem.

Doctors say he is overweight. This is apparently due to insufficient physical activity and the medication he took for insomnia while in prison. In Katmandu, he got four new teeth as his teeth had decayed and for some reason he could not get them fixed while in prison.

Govinda has gone through enormous emotional and mental distress for a very long period. That has left deep psychological scars.

In the first few weeks after he returned, he showed symptoms such as becoming euphoric one moment and getting extremely irritable the next. He also seemed to be struggling to cope with the new environment.

We have showered a lot of love on him, believing love and warmth will help him build new and better memories. We have been working hard to build an environment in which he can feel comfortable. And he has responded quite well to our efforts.

He is recovering fast compared to what has been reported to be the case of others with similar stories and so far, there hasn't been a need to put him on medication.

Govinda mostly stays at home as he has yet to develop confidence to leave his house alone.

He is also concerned about his safety. Some people in Nepal believe that he returned with sacks full of compensation money after winning the court case, although this is not the case. But given the law and order situation in Nepal these days, a man who is thought to have loads of cash can become a target of criminals.

The only places he has traveled to after returning to Nepal is the tourist city of Pokhara and the Nagarkot area on the outskirts of Katmandu. We accompanied him during these trips.

Govinda spends time reading books and newspapers. He read many books while in prison, and some of them touched him deeply. He likes to reread them, and has also been reading some new books.

We are expecting hearings on Govinda's retrial to end on Oct. 29 and we presume some more days will be needed for the high court to announce its final verdict.

Thereafter, we believe the Japanese government will compensate Govinda according to Japan's laws for his wrongful imprisonment.

Govinda will not seek to go to Japan to claim compensation. His bad memories are too recent to make him comfortable with the idea of going to Japan again. Even if he overcomes those memories, he might not get a visa as he was deported. So it is up to our lawyers to do (what is necessary).

Fifteen years in prison have turned Govinda into a man who cannot take up a normal profession. The most we expect from him is the role of a social worker.

He is interested in working for the betterment of the lives of those who have gone through his kind of ordeal and he believes working for such people will help him forget his inner wounds.

But for that, he needs to successfully go through this transition to a new life as a free man and he still needs to develop a lot of confidence to become a social worker.

The misfortune that befell Govinda has preoccupied us for 15 years now.

For me, it has been like juggling several jobs simultaneously apart from my real job, which is that of tourism professional. Apart from my work, I have been taking care of legal matters and have also been looking after Govinda's family.

In the past few months, there were days when I (fielded) hundreds of phone calls from journalists every day and even nowadays there are times when many of them call me up whenever there is any development in the buildup to the retrial. But given the way things have been shaping up, I can't complain.

There were moments when we were in despair. The moment of deepest despair was when Japan's Supreme Court upheld Govinda's conviction. That day, we felt we would never get him back. We had hoped for so much from the Supreme Court.

I am confident the test we have been through will end very soon. I can't thank enough a group of Japanese citizens who for 15 years out of pure humanitarian instincts functioned as a bridge between Govinda and his family in Nepal.

I hope others who might have been wrongfully imprisoned in different corners of the world will be able to take heart from Govinda's story.


 
Posted on 10-29-12 8:52 AM     [Snapshot: 64]     Reply [Subscribe]
Login in to Rate this Post:     0       ?    
 

"We are extremely sorry for keeping him detained for a very long time," - thant is really disgusting way to apologize.
 
Posted on 10-29-12 9:08 AM     [Snapshot: 103]     Reply [Subscribe]
Login in to Rate this Post:     0       ?    
 

Law of country should include provisions to punish lawmakers who inflict punishment upon innocent people.

Saying sorry is just not enough.

 
Posted on 10-29-12 9:28 AM     [Snapshot: 136]     Reply [Subscribe]
Login in to Rate this Post:     0       ?    
 

"The DNA in a sample taken from the victim’s nails did not match that of Mainali but it matched that of semen found inside the victim's body leading to the Tokyo High Court granting him a retrial, according to the Kyodo News Agency".

My question is , How  the girl who was killed got the semen inside her body? Was she a call girl and Mr. Mainali was engaged?

 Can Mainali sue for imprisoned for his jailed time? 

 
Posted on 10-29-12 2:33 PM     [Snapshot: 427]     Reply [Subscribe]
Login in to Rate this Post:     0       ?    
 

NO one can return his time back and the mental torture he and  his  family have gone through.
Is there any sort of compensation as he moves forward from this point of life ?

Justice Delayed ~ Justice Denied

 
Posted on 10-30-12 6:46 AM     [Snapshot: 806]     Reply [Subscribe]
Login in to Rate this Post:     0       ?    
 

This is too much.
 


Please Log in! to be able to reply! If you don't have a login, please register here.

YOU CAN ALSO



IN ORDER TO POST!




Within last 7 days
Recommended Popular Threads Controvertial Threads
I hope all the fake Nepali refugee get deported
Those who are in TPS, what’s your backup plan?
Travel Document for TPS (approved)
MAGA and all how do you feel about Trumps cabinet pick?
NOTE: The opinions here represent the opinions of the individual posters, and not of Sajha.com. It is not possible for sajha.com to monitor all the postings, since sajha.com merely seeks to provide a cyber location for discussing ideas and concerns related to Nepal and the Nepalis. Please send an email to admin@sajha.com using a valid email address if you want any posting to be considered for deletion. Your request will be handled on a one to one basis. Sajha.com is a service please don't abuse it. - Thanks.

Sajha.com Privacy Policy

Like us in Facebook!

↑ Back to Top
free counters